Philosophy – Essay Example
1) From your reading of Hasker, and using the categories he uses, what view of the mind/body problem do you think is exhibited by Picard? By Maddox? Support your answer.
Picard – Materialism
Maddox – Dualism
The way Maddox talks about Data as an “it” suggests that he is a Dualist. He thinks that what makes the human mind special is that it is somehow unique, like having a soul. Hasker talks about Dualism as a way of describing how the mind is completely non-physical (66). Since it is not created by physical interactions, just having a brain is not sufficient to be intelligent. Because Data is not human, he has no soul and is just a thing.
Picard, on the other hand, thinks more Materialistically. He argues that human beings are just machines of a sort. This is very similar to the idea of a “meat machine” that Hasker mentions (70). Essentially, what creates the mind/soul in this idea is a complicated physical computer-like system inside of our heads. By this worldview, Data could easily be a sentient being, because he is one big complicated computer-like system himself.
b) Do you think that artificial intelligence to the level as it is presented in the story will someday be possible? Why or why not?
I do think it will someday be possible to make artificial intelligence. However, I don’t know if they would ever be put into human-shaped bodies. Computer advances are happening very rapidly all the time, so it seems reasonable that we will eventually be able to build computers that are aware of their own actions and existence, as well as being incredibly more intelligent than living human beings.
I think the reason these machines will not be put into human bodies is because of things like in the Star Trek episode. Not only will some people be uncomfortable with the idea of smarter-than-human computers, but putting them in human bodies will make it look too much like playing God.
Star Trek: The Next Generation
“The Measure of a Man”
Most of us are aware that the television series Star Trek was about a starship, the Enterprise, whose mission was to explore the galaxy. This ship was part of a larger organization known as Starfleet. Serving as a Lt. Commander on board the ship was an android named Data. Data was an extremely advanced and unique android even by the standards of 24th century science. He had a special processor known as a “positronic brain”that allowed him to mimic human behavior in an extremely accurate manner. As a result, not only could he process information at lightning speed and arrive at rational conclusions, he also seemed to have desires, interests, and inclinations. He could formulate relationships and make free choices.
In this episode, Commander Bruce Maddox, a member of the scientific research division of Starfleet, arrives on board the Enterprise with orders for Data to be transferred to him for the purpose of being disassembled with the goal of learning more about “it”(Maddox refers to Data as “it”, not “him”, throughout the entire episode). His ultimate goal is to create an army of androids like Data which can serve the needs of Starfleet in space exploration. When Data learns that Maddox may not be able to reassemble him, he refuses to submit to the orders and is supported by Captain Picard, captain of the Enterprise and Data’s commanding officer. Picard argues that, as an officer on the Enterprise, Data has rightsâ€”among them the right to refuse to undergo an experimental procedure such as this. However, Picard is unsuccessful in getting the transfer orders rescinded and so Data resigns from Starfleet.
Maddox takes legal action with the local JAG (Judge Advocate General) officer challenging Data’s resignation and arguing that Data is not a person with a right to resign, but, being a machine, “it”is the property of Starfleet. He argues “Would you permit the computer of the Enterprise to refuse a refit?”going on to claim that Picard’s reaction is, “emotional and irrational. You are endowing Data with human characteristics because it looks human, but it is not. If it were a box on wheels I would not be facing this opposition.”
The JAG officer concurs with Maddox and rules that Data is the property of Starfleet and cannot resign or refuse to co-operate. Picard requests a hearing to challenge the ruling and is placed in the position of being the defending attorney for Data while his senior officer, Commander Riker, is given the unenviable job of prosecuting attorney.
Riker opens his case by having Data define android which Data defines as “an automaton made to resemble a human being.”Riker emphasizes “automaton”and “resembles.”After demonstrating Data’s abilities as a machine, Riker summarizes his argument:
The commander is a physical representation of a dream; an idea conceived of by the mind of a man. Its purpose â€“ to serve human needs and interests. It’s a collection of neural nets and heuristic algorithms. It’s response dictated by elaborate software written by a man. It’s hardware built by a man. And now a man will shut it off.
With that Riker reaches behind Data and turns the switch that shuts him down say “Pinocchio is broken. His strings have been cut.”
During a recess in the proceedings, Picard consults with Guinan, a wise alien on board the Enterprise and becomes convinced that the real issue in this case is the creation of a race of Data’s to be enslaved to do man’s bidding. He believes this issue has been obscured “behind a comfortable, easy euphemism “ property”and is determined to challenge that thinking.
In his opening defense Picard acknowledges that Data is a machine but comments that this is irrelevant, “We too are machines, just machines of a different type.”He also acknowledges that, as Data was created by a human, so are we, “Children are created from the building blocks of their parents DNA. Are they property?”He then asks Data a series of questions demonstrating that, like any person, he has wants and desires, values things, and forms deep personal relationships.
Picard then calls Maddox to the stand and asks for the definition of a sentient being. Maddox offers three criteria: “Intelligence, self-awareness and consciousness.”Picard goes on to ask Maddox to “prove to the court that I am sentient.”When Maddox claims that Picard’s sentience is obvious, Picard asks what the difference between himself and Data is. Maddox replies that Picard is self-aware (he acknowledges the first criteria of Data’s intelligence) and defines self-aware as “Conscious of your existence and actions. You are aware of yourself and your own ego.”
Picard turns to Data and asks him what he is currently doing. Data replies, “I am taking part in a legal hearing to determine my rights and status: am I a person or property.”When asked what is at stake, he replies, “My right to choose. Perhaps my very life.”Picard points out how often Data refers to himself in his reply, “My rights, my status, my right to choose, my life. He seems reasonably self-aware to me.”He then asks Maddox, “What if Data can fulfill the last criteria, consciousness, in even the smallest degree? What is he then? Do you know?”He asks the same question of Riker and the JAG officer and goes on to say, “Starfleet was founded to seek out new life, well there it sits.”Picard argues that if we create an army of Datas to do man’s bidding, then “Thousands of Datas become a race. Won’t we be judged by how we treat that race?”
After considering the arguments, the JAG officer makes her final ruling:
It sits there looking at me and I don’t know what it is. This case has dealt with metaphysics - with questions best left to saints and philosophers. I am neither competent nor qualified to answer those. But I’ve got to make a ruling to speak to the future. Is Data a machine? Yes. Is he the property of Starfleet? No. We have been dancing around the basic issue: Does Data have a soul? I don’t know that he has. I don’t know that I have. But I have got to give him the freedom to explore that question himself. It is the ruling of this court that Lt. Commander Data has the right to choose.
Data exercises his right to refuse to undergo the procedure encouraging Maddox to continue his research. Maddox agrees to rescind his request for transfer, commenting about Data that “He’s remarkable.”
If you do nto have access to the book mentioned above I will see if I can get the pages scanned and emailed.